1. "You're one of 200 people I'm cold calling."It might seem flattering to receive a cold call or email from a recruiter about a position they're trying to fill. However in order to get a few candidates into an interview pipeline the typical recruiter had to start by contacting 200 or more people with the right keywords on their bio. While it may seem you were one of a chosen few that had just the right background of what their client is looking for, you're actually one of hundreds that had the right keywords their recruiter searched for to start their interview funnel.
2.
"You're being interviewed to make my other candidates look better."If you've ever purchased a house you might have noticed that the house you wound up purchasing wasn't the first house your real estate agent showed you. It was probably the third or fourth. That was no accident. The first few houses you were shown were carefully staged in order for the house the agent thought you may like look that much better. Recruiters often use the same technique.
Hiring managers rarely have a detailed understanding of what their ideal interview candidate is and generally do not want to make an offer to the first person in the interview process. Recruiters know this and therefore insert into the interview process "calibration candidates". These are interview candidates that the recruiter doesn't believe are the best fit for the job, but will help make their chosen candidate look that much better when they are interviewed by their client.
3. "I get measured by how quickly I fill a job opening."Larger companies often employ a staff of in-house recruiters, many as temporary contractors, to fill their open positions. The metric most often used to measure an in-house recruiter's performance is the average number of days to fill an open position. The quality of the people hired is not easily measured until long after the newly recruited individual is on the job. So the recruiter is motivated to bring in the lowest caliber interview candidates that are just above the bar for hiring over spending the much greater effort to find truly exceptional candidates.
4. "I'm using your confidential resume to market my firm to new companies."Contingency recruiting firms market themselves to new corporate customers by showing them a select group of resumes of people they "represent". However they might not actually be representing them at all. The next time you agree to send your resume to a recruiting firm they might be turning it around and using it to market themselves to new clients. I initially learned of this technique after agreeing to give my resume to a recruiting firm and later discovering they were using it as a sales tool to prospective clients. In no way was this firm "representing me".
5. "Last month I was selling subprime mortgages."Recruiters are sales people. They sell candidates to hiring managers and new companies/positions to candidates. While the top retained search firms employ highly skilled and experienced professionals, many contingency recruiters jumped into the field from some other sales domain - timeshares in Florida, brokering subprime mortages, .....
Photo by alanclarkdesign